Victoria's Secret v. Thomas Pink: The Fight Over PINK

Two companies. One four-letter word. Two countries' courts. Victoria's Secret has sued the British shirtmaker Thomas Pink in federal court in Ohio, claiming Thomas Pink's new women's casualwear line infringes its PINK trademarks. The twist is that the two brands signed a peace treaty over that exact word more than a decade ago. This is a story about what happens when a brand grows past the deal it made, and it is a lesson for every founder who has ever shaken hands with a competitor over a name.
What happened between Victoria's Secret and Thomas Pink?
Thomas Pink started in London in 1984 as a shirtmaker, famous for men's dress shirts and suiting. Victoria's Secret launched its PINK line years later and built it into a major name in young women's loungewear and casual clothing.
The two names first collided in the United Kingdom. According to the law firm summary published by KJK, Thomas Pink sued when Victoria's Secret brought PINK to the U.K., and in 2014 the English High Court ruled for Thomas Pink, finding that Victoria's Secret's use of PINK infringed Thomas Pink's U.K. and EU trademark registrations.
In 2015, the companies settled with a global agreement that set out how both brands could live side by side. According to Victoria's Secret's complaint, as summarized by KJK, the settlement preserved its right to object if Thomas Pink used PINK outside its traditional shirt-and-suit business.
Fast forward to 2025 and 2026. Victoria's Secret gave written consent to several of Thomas Pink's U.S. trademark applications, including a PINK design with striped lettering and several PINK LONDON trademarks. Victoria's Secret says it understood those filings would stay inside Thomas Pink's traditional lane.
Then, on August 13, 2026, Victoria's Secret says it found women's T-shirts, leggings, sweatshirts and sweatpants carrying a plain PINK, without the stripes and without LONDON. It objected the next day. Talks followed. On September 11, 2026, it filed suit, as first reported by Bloomberg Law.
Who is being sued, and what does Victoria's Secret want?
The public docket lists seven defendants: Thomas Pink Shirtmaker LLC, Original Pink, LLC, C-Life Group, Ltd., Icon Trade Services LLC (doing business as Icon Luxury Group), Cutie Pie Baby, Inc. (doing business as CP Brands Group), YM, Inc., and Fashion Nova, LLC. The case is assigned to Judge Edmund A. Sargus.
Notice who is on that list. It is not only the brand owner. It includes the licensing side, the manufacturer and the retailers. When a trademark owner goes after a product line, everyone who touches the product can end up named.
On the same day it filed the complaint, Victoria's Secret asked for a preliminary injunction, which is a court order that would stop the sales while the case is pending, and for expedited discovery. As of the public docket entries we reviewed, no ruling on either request was shown.
According to KJK's summary of the filings, Victoria's Secret says its evidence includes a consumer survey with a 35% net confusion rate, social media posts calling the products "Pink dupes," more than two decades of use, U.S. PINK sales approaching $2 billion a year, and aided consumer awareness above 80%. These are Victoria's Secret's allegations and its own numbers. Thomas Pink disputes the claims, and no court has accepted or rejected them yet.
What did the English court decide?
Here is where it gets international. Thomas Pink went to the High Court in London and asked for an anti-suit injunction, an order that would have stopped Victoria's Secret from pursuing the Ohio case. Thomas Pink argued the 2015 agreement sends disputes about its meaning to the English courts.
The court said no. In Thomas Pink Shirtmaker LLC v Victoria's Secret Stores Brand Management LLC [2026] EWHC 2817, reported by the Solicitors Journal on November 6, 2026, Deputy Judge Justin Turner KC preferred Victoria's Secret's reading of the key clause. As reported, he read the deal as turning on trademark branding, not on which company owns the brand. A small THOMAS PINK label sewn inside the garments did not change his view.
That ruling did not decide whether Thomas Pink infringes in the United States. It decided where the fight can happen. The judge also declined Victoria's Secret's broader requests for now, and indicated any declaration should be limited to the goods in the Ohio case.
What is a trademark coexistence agreement?
A coexistence agreement is a contract between two businesses with similar names. It spells out who can use the name, for what products, in which markets and in what style, so both can operate without suing each other. Big brands sign them all the time. They are often the smartest way out of a dispute, because a settlement costs far less than a trial and gives both sides certainty.
There is a close cousin called a consent agreement. When one company's trademark application is blocked by another company's registration, the owner of the registration can sign a written consent saying the two can coexist. The USPTO's likelihood of confusion guidance explains the test examiners apply: how similar the trademarks are, and how related the goods and services are. A well-drafted consent explains why confusion is unlikely, and examiners give those agreements real weight.
But a coexistence deal is only as good as its definitions. Words like "traditional business," "associated with," "range of products" and "field of use" carry enormous weight years later, when one side grows into something new. That appears to be the heart of this dispute.
Why does expanding your product line change the risk?
Trademark rights are not about a word in the abstract. They are about a word used for particular goods or services. Thomas Pink's PINK on a men's dress shirt and Victoria's Secret's PINK on a pair of leggings lived in different worlds for years. Put both PINKs on women's casualwear and the worlds overlap.
That is the legal idea behind likelihood of confusion. It is also why Victoria's Secret pleads dilution. Federal law gives famous trademarks extra protection against uses that blur their distinctiveness or tarnish their reputation, even without proof of confusion (15 U.S.C. § 1125(c)). According to KJK, Victoria's Secret points to online comments calling the products "cheap" as evidence of harm to its reputation. Whether PINK qualifies as famous, and whether the claims hold up, is for the court to decide.
Here is the takeaway in plain English. The license you have today covers the business you have today. When you add a new product category, a new market or a new look, ask whether your old agreements, consents and clearance still cover you. Often they do not.
What should founders learn from the PINK dispute?
Read your old deals before you launch something new. If you ever settled a name dispute, signed a coexistence agreement, gave or got a consent, or licensed a name, pull the document out before you expand. The definitions you agreed to years ago may decide whether your new line is safe.
Draft for the business you will become. If you are negotiating a coexistence deal now, think five years ahead. Spell out product categories, channels, logos and styles, and how either side can expand. Vague words feel friendly at signing and expensive in court.
Clear the name for every new category, not just the first one. A clearance search for your first product does not clear your second. Before you put your brand on a new kind of product, run a fresh search for that category.
Watch your licensees and partners. The Ohio complaint names the licensing side, the manufacturer and the retailers. If you license your brand, your agreement should control which products carry it and who answers if a claim comes in.
Monitor your trademark. Victoria's Secret says it spotted the products and objected the very next day. Speed matters. Owners who are not watching the marketplace and the USPTO register often find out after the window for the cheapest fix has closed. Our guide on why trademark monitoring matters explains how that works.
Treat a demand letter seriously, but calmly. If you receive one, our guide to cease and desist letters walks through what to preserve and how to respond. And if you are about to rebrand or extend a brand, read our piece on rebranding trademark risks first.
How can you check your own brand before you expand?
Start with a real clearance search for the exact products you plan to sell. My Nationwide Trademark Clearance Search covers the federal register, all 50 states, and marketplace and common law uses. I review the results and walk you through them on a Search Results Call, booked when you order and held within 3 business days. Your written report follows the call. You can see exactly what you get in our sample search report.
The search is $679 flat per trademark, nonrefundable. If your path is clear and you move forward, application preparation and filing is $1,800 flat per trademark, and the USPTO filing fee of $350 per class is paid by you directly through your own USPTO.gov account, with my firm set up as Fee Payer. Office action responses are quoted separately.
Frequently asked questions
Why is Victoria's Secret suing Thomas Pink?
Victoria's Secret claims that Thomas Pink's new PINK-branded women's casualwear infringes and dilutes its PINK trademarks and goes beyond what the brands agreed in their 2015 settlement. The case was filed on September 11, 2026, in the Southern District of Ohio. These are allegations, and Thomas Pink disputes them.
Didn't Thomas Pink win against Victoria's Secret before?
Yes. In 2014, the English High Court ruled that Victoria's Secret's use of PINK infringed Thomas Pink's U.K. and EU trademark registrations. The companies settled worldwide in 2015 with a coexistence agreement, and the current dispute is largely about what that agreement allows.
What is a trademark coexistence agreement?
A trademark coexistence agreement is a contract between two businesses with similar names that sets out who can use the name, for which products and in which markets. It lets both brands operate without litigation. Its protection depends on how clearly the parties defined each side's field of business.
Can two companies use the same trademark?
Two companies can use the same word as a trademark when their goods or services are different enough that customers are not likely to be confused, often under a coexistence or consent agreement. The risk rises when one company expands into the other's product category, which is the situation alleged in the PINK case.
What is trademark dilution?
Trademark dilution is a claim available to owners of famous trademarks under 15 U.S.C. § 1125(c). It protects a famous trademark against uses that blur its distinctiveness or tarnish its reputation, even without proof that customers are confused. Whether a trademark is famous is a demanding standard that courts decide case by case.
Do I need a new trademark search when I add a product line?
Yes, in most cases. A clearance search answers whether a name is available for specific goods or services, so a search for your first product does not clear a new category. Before you put your brand on a new kind of product, search that category and check any agreements that limit how you can use the name.
Sources
- Victoria's Secret Stores Brand Management LLC v. Thomas Pink Shirtmaker LLC et al., No. 2:26-cv-01129 (S.D. Ohio), docket via Justia
- Bloomberg Law, September 11, 2026
- KJK, September 24, 2026
- Solicitors Journal, November 6, 2026
- 15 U.S.C. § 1125, via Cornell LII
- USPTO, Likelihood of confusion
By Kendra Stephen, Esq., The Lady Lawyer®, trademark attorney and founder of BrandProtector.com.
Last updated November 16, 2026. This article reports on pending litigation; the claims described are allegations, and no court has ruled on the merits. It is general information, not legal advice for your situation. Attorney advertising.
Find out if your name is available
A $679 flat-fee trademark search shows you what stands in the way before you invest in your brand.
ORDER YOUR CLEARANCE SEARCH: $679Attorney-reviewed, 3-business-day report, Nationwide






